(262) 200-2535

Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

Phillip Bergman



Diane M Hamberger


Absolutely wonderful work. I had a broken prong. They replaced the center head. I have had work done on the head from the original designer, but it was never done as well as this. The store is beautiful and reasonable. You can see the pride, in the work that they do. This is now my jeweler.

Jude Hust


From the minute I enter the your store you made me feel welcome Jennifer was so helpful and knowledgeable with my jewelry. My repair on my ring was done very fast and it looks beautiful!!
Everyone on your staff is very friendly and knowledgeable!! Joe Barnes is wonderful too!! Thank yo so much!!

Scott Nethery


Awesome store...Jessica is best..she helped me to design a one of a kind wedding ring, and it turned to be fabulous!
Thanks Jessica

Dylan Dreger


I worked with Jessica to find an engagement ring. I was very impressed with the service. There was never a time where I felt like I was getting a sales pitch. I originally went only to get ideas but went back because of the service. Jessica really took the time to figure out exactly what we wanted. And even though it took multiple changes help me to customize the perfect ring!

Dave Morgenson


It is a wonder experience every time we go into Barnes Jewelry. This is a beautiful store with an extremely large selection to choose from. The staff is very knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with. Dave M

Cindy Freer


Great staff, so helpful and knowledgeable. Repairs done quickly and at a fair price.

B. Wudtke


What an amazing experience I had dealing with your jeweler Jennifer. She did an amazing job and went way above and beyond getting my order in store. I’ll be a customer for life!!! I couldn’t have asked for a better jeweler and experience, so thank you!

Vicky Brinkmann


The staff at Barnes Jewelers are all extremely helpful, knowledgeable, and courteous. I took a damaged ring in that was purchased elsewhere. I arrived at the store about 20 minutes before closing.

They took extra time to explain to us things about this ring that we didn’t know- even though they didn’t sell it to us. They gave us several options and we were able to leave with some peace of mind, and a beautiful solution. By the time I left the store it was 30 minutes past closing time. They never made me feel rushed.

I have taken several pieces to Barnes and have never been disappointed.

I will recommend Barnes Jewelers to everyone!
Thank you!

Kristin B


Jennifer was very patient and helpful as we worked together to design a new engagement ring and wedding band to commemorate our 30th anniversary. She clearly listened to my preferences and made sure every detail was perfect.
I love my new rings and my husband beams when he sees me wearing them. As a bonus, the finished products were delivered about 2 weeks ahead of schedule!
Thank you for making this process so much fun.

LuAnn Hermann

Not Rated


We do all of our fine jewelry purchases and maintenance at Barnes. They are a wonderful trusted family business and treat us like family. Thanks so much.

Susan Benishek


This wasn’t my first visit to Barnes... it certainly won’t be my last. My husband surprised me with a beautiful jade ring (35th Anniversary) that was from the estate section of the store. 100+ years, gorgeous but a little too small. I brought it in today for sizing and was told 4 days and it would be ready. Well, the goldsmith overheard me tell one of the ladies that it’s too bad I couldn’t take it on a trip with me the next morning and he came out and promised he could have it ready in 4 hours. That was the most thoughtful customer service I’ve ever received and my husband will be thrilled when he notices that I’m wearing the ring on our trip! Thanks to you all at Barnes Jewlers!

Colleen Schultz

Not Rated


Jessica Barnes assisted me and did an outstanding job. She is friendly, courteous, and VERY knowledgeable. I am SO excited to be picking up my ring with a beautiful new emerald set in it later this week. Thank you, Jessica.
—-Colleen Schultz

Joshua Loeffelholz


Wow, where do I even start!?
About 2 months ago I placed an order at a large corporate jewelry store ( I’ll leave unnamed). Upon placing the order the saleswoman told me I would be notified in about 6-8 weeks when the “special order” arrives in store. At 7 weeks I received a call telling me that my ring has arrived, but unfortunately they received the wrong ring. My heart sank when they told me I would have to wait another 6-8 weeks for new ring to arrive, and then another couple days for them to put it together. I had made plans to ask the girl of my dreams to marry me the following week after I was originally supposed to receive the ring, so needless to say I was devistated . After telling my father my situation he immediately referred me to Barnes. This was the greatest advice I had ever received! Within 1 hour I was at the store speaking with Rita, telling her my situation. She showed me some rings, (all of which looked amazing) and I found the exact ring I had pictured in my head. She paired it with the most beautiful diamond that I’d ever seen, and told me she could have it ready within the week. Two days later my phone rang, and to my amazement it was Rita telling me that they had finished my ring early. She was a life saver! The ring is stunning, and I couldn’t be happier. To Rita, and the entire staff I say THANK YOU! You turned a devistating moment into the greatest twist of fate I could have ever hoped for! Barnes has gained a life long customer in me!

Tatum Hain


My husband and I had our rings created by Barnes Jewelers. The end results are constantly getting praises. The process was easy, exciting, and surprisingly affordable. The next design we want created will be coming from Barnes.

Current Rating in Google: 4.8 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Greg Brazgel

April 1, 2022

The staff at Barnes Jewelers was wonderful! Extremely helpful and friendly! They went above and beyond to make our experience fabulous! My wedding ring needed repair. It looks just like the day my husband proposed 24 years ago❤️

Zach Chudy

October 9, 2021

Great service incredibly helpful Jennifer is fantastic helped me get a ring in time to make it a special day

Kevin Keller

October 18, 2021

Looking for an honest to goodness, caring, and professional jeweler, Barnes and Co. is your shop. We worked with them from March - October 2021 and received only this highest quality service, personal touch, and pieces. There's was no pressure and Rachel was very responsive to our needs and desires. She was a lot of fun to work with as well! I would gladly recommend this shop and Rachel to family and friends. We did shop around and speak with several jewelers, and Barnes was by far the top tier leaving others in the dust. Most jewelers either didn't seem to care about helping us find the best rings or rushed us. Barnes did the complete opposite. They have several collections to choose from and are able to customize rings based on preferences. They communicate readily and honestly about everything from design to production and payment to delivery of goods. Do yourself a favor, skip the other shops and focus your energy on the shop that does the job well--Barnes and Co.. Thank you so much, Rachel!!! It'll be great working with you again!

Brandon Barber

September 21, 2021

Rude staff. Lost a customer that was willing to spend $2000. I guess what cloths I wear matter to how I'm treated.